
Education has eliminated the need to learn and replaced that
essential aspect of knowledge with disproven and often damaging prospect of testing. Testing has transformed the universal
prospect of an educated populous into a statistical driven business that
heightens the act of the test to a supreme status, diminishing education and knowledge
and the heavenly achievement of learning just to learn.
It is important to evaluate our present levels and to gauge
our understanding in order to more effectively plan how to learn or teach but
the prospect of testing and grading is repugnant to the simple and humble
process of learning. In life we learn
from our mistakes and our successes, the grading of our lives never really
ending. We may obtain an A+ in some
areas of our lives and a D or worse in others but those grades never determine
our placement for the future. A grade is
only a snapshot of where we are now not for the rest of forever.
Testing a student in math or science is essential in order
to understand those present levels of understanding but almost universally
those grades are static and fixed points of failure with only the top tier
students gaining success and future promise of success. A good example would be using a simple bell
curve of any class to illustrate how learning is not the so called adopted
process of our present education model. Approximately
16% of all students excel in any given subject (those earning a B or better)
the rest of the students achieve substantially less on each test, receiving a grade
of C or worse.
For those who achieve
they have learned most of what taught or at least tested, while those who
failed to achieve a B or better are in a serious deficit. 30% of the required knowledge is forsaken at the
C level with 40% for D and 50% for F.
This is the reality of testing; it is not a function of learning. For learning to be supreme those who have not achieved at least
80% understanding should be re-taught and reinforced before they can move on to
the next chapter. Almost all learning is
accumulative and without the foundational process extra learning is hopeless
and a complete waste of time and resources.
If a student is consistently a C student (a passing student)
then by end of the year that student only has a rudimentary grasp on the
essential aspects of those “important” topics we deem to be indispensable for
future success. The question must be
asked, is it better to have 100% of a portion of a house or 70% of every part
of the house? You can ponder and decide
which is better.
Education in the United States is falling further and
further behind almost every other industrialized nation and many poorer
countries as well and the reason for that failure is simply because we do not
demand that our student learn. We test,
we drill, we advance with only partial understanding and expect our children to
be able to build an entire house with only 40, 50 or even 70% of the needed
materials. It can’t be done. One can build a livable and safe enclosure
with less if the list is complete but no one can build a life of promise when a
substantial portion of the needed information is missing.
A little
learning is a dangerous thing;
Drink deep, or taste not the Pierian spring:
There shallow draughts intoxicate the brain,
And drinking largely sobers us again.
Drink deep, or taste not the Pierian spring:
There shallow draughts intoxicate the brain,
And drinking largely sobers us again.
And for those
who do not fully understand the statement above was first coined by Alexander Pope,
an 18th Century poet (21
May 1688 – 30 May 1744).
And for those
who need further explanation, Pope is telling us all that it’s better not to
drink or learn at all unless were willing to drink deep from that well and
learn deeply. For those who only suck
the bug infested upper waters will forever have bugs in their teeth. Ignorance is bliss some say and perhaps their
right for once you start to learn ignorance is lost and the only way toward
bliss is to embrace the light of learning, drinking deeply from the well of all
knowledge.
Our schools, our administrators promote only the skim and
sheen of a polished exterior, leaving the depth of those brains empty and
grasping, never knowing the strength of truly understanding. At least a few are making a good living, even
if it is at the expense of our future and the future of this once great
country.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Think before you comment....